home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=90TT2317>
- <link 93TG0121>
- <link 91TT0202>
- <link 90TT2191>
- <title>
- Sep. 03, 1990: The Petro Panic
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1990
- Sep. 03, 1990 Are We Ready For This?
- The Gulf:Desert Shield
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- NATION, Page 49
- The Petro Panic
- </hdr>
- <body>
- <p>Fearing war and dreading an oil shock, the financial markets
- sink into a frenzy of selling. For the U.S. economy, the
- outlook is stagnant--at best.
- </p>
- <p>By George J. Church--Reported by Anne Constable/London,
- Michael Duffy/Washington and Thomas McCarroll/New York
- </p>
- <p> Leftist radicals who think capitalism thrives on war must
- have wondered what on earth to make of last week. The prospect
- of combat in the Persian Gulf touched off something resembling
- panic throughout the financial world. Stock prices sank rapidly
- in New York City, Tokyo, London, Paris, Frankfurt. At the lows
- on Thursday, shares of all U.S. stocks had lost more than $600
- billion in paper value in slightly over a month, more than in
- the Black Monday crash of October 1987; on the Tokyo exchange,
- cumulative losses since the start of the year came to well over
- $1 trillion. Bond prices dropped in sympathy, sending interest
- rates spiraling; the yield on bellwether U.S. Treasury 30-year
- bonds Thursday hit an extraordinary 9.13%, the highest since
- April 1989. The dollar, which is losing its reputation as a
- safe haven, fell hard against nearly all other major
- currencies, touching a lowest ever rate of 1.54 against the
- deutsche mark.
- </p>
- <p> On Friday markets generally steadied as traders and
- investors began to suspect that the earlier nose dive had been
- an overreaction: nothing so absolutely awful had happened yet.
- In Manhattan the Dow Jones industrial average climbed 49 points
- to a close of 2532.92--still down 112 points, or 4.2%, for
- the week and more than 460 points, or 16%, below its July 16
- high of just under 3000. But no one could be sure that the
- worst was over. Some markets, notably bonds, kept right on
- going down. More important, the threat of war has not begun to
- fade, and the markets are operating on a frightening equation:
- war equals oil shortages equals skyrocketing petroleum prices
- equals an upsurge in general inflation plus sagging profits,
- lower production and more unemployment--all at the same time.
- J. Richard Fredericks, a banking analyst at Montgomery
- Securities, a San Francisco brokerage, summarizes the thinking:
- "The gulf crisis has fueled the fears of rising inflation,
- deficits, recession and stagflation. That's a wicked
- combination."
- </p>
- <p> Some of these worries might come true even without a war.
- The price of crude oil for October delivery leaped to $32.35
- per bbl. at one point last Thursday, the highest since futures
- trading began in 1983, and closed Friday at $30.91, drastically
- above the $18 spot price that prevailed only a month ago. The
- worldwide embargo of Iraqi and Kuwaiti oil has removed about
- 4 million bbl. a day from international trade, and doubts are
- growing that other producers can make up the shortfall. Some
- experts are skeptical that Saudi Arabia can increase its
- production of crude quite as much as the 2 million bbl. daily
- it has promised. The Saudis notified customers last week that
- there would be no increase at all in their deliveries of
- refined products to the world market, since the gasoline and
- jet fuel would be needed at home to supply Saudi and American
- planes and tanks defending the oil wells against Iraqi forces.
- </p>
- <p> The results are likely to be especially severe in the U.S.,
- which is uncomfortably vulnerable to any shock. Economists are
- debating whether the economy is merely on the brink of a
- recession or already in one. Output of goods and services grew
- only 1.2% in the second quarter, the fifth straight quarter of
- growth below 2%. That is likely to spark a continuing increase
- in unemployment, which rose last month to 5.5%, the highest
- since August 1988. Corporate profits have declined 12% in the
- first half, and are likely to sink further, in part because
- higher interest rates are making it more difficult for many
- corporations to pay off their swollen debts. Consumers also are
- too heavily in debt to increase their spending much.
- </p>
- <p> The public has turned increasingly pessimistic. In a
- TIME/CNN poll taken last week by Yankelovich Clancy Shulman,
- 59% of the adults surveyed said they expect a recession, up
- from 55% two weeks ago. The vast majority expect conditions to
- deteriorate: 66% anticipate rising unemployment, 75% foresee
- higher interest rates, and 86% believe inflation will increase.
- They have good reason for gloom, beyond the tendency for such
- fears to become self-fulfilling prophecies. Big oil-price
- increases act like a stiff tax increase, pulling money out of
- consumers' pockets and reducing their ability to buy other
- products. A rule of thumb is that an annual increase of $8 per
- bbl. in oil prices reduces economic growth 1 percentage point
- a year. But petroleum has already risen more than that, and
- subtracting a point from growth leaves almost nothing. So if
- prices stay put, says a Bush Administration official, "growth
- is going to be a giant goose egg for the year. A big fat zero."
- </p>
- <p> And that is an optimistic scenario. Continuing large price
- boosts, especially if produced by a protracted war on the
- Arabian Peninsula, could bring what a government official calls
- a "deep, deep recession." Worse yet, it would be an
- inflationary recession. Oil-price increases push up the cost
- of not only gasoline and heating fuel but also everything else
- made from petrochemicals: detergents, paint, ink, plastics and
- anything packaged in them, to name only a few. Anthony
- Vignola, chief economist of the Kidder Peabody brokerage firm,
- figures that if the recent rise of crude oil to almost $32 per
- bbl. is not rolled back, consumer prices this quarter will jump
- at an annual rate of 8.6%, nearly double their recent pace.
- </p>
- <p> Worst of all, there seems to be little that government can
- do to head off such trouble. The conventional remedy for
- recession is deficit spending--but the budget deficit is so
- swollen there is little room to pump it up further. The Federal
- Reserve Board is in an especially impossible position. To ward
- off or soften recession, the Fed would normally lower interest
- rates; to combat inflation, it would raise them. To fight both
- together, it should do--what? The conventional wisdom is
- stumped for an answer. The time to move was much earlier: wise
- policy could have reduced U.S. dependence on imported oil and
- lowered the deficit during the prosperous years. By doing
- neither, the nation made itself vulnerable to an outside shock;
- it is all too likely to pay a stiff price now.
- </p>
- <p> Other industrialized countries are, on the whole, in better
- shape than the U.S. to withstand an oil shock. Although their
- dependence on imported oil generally, and Persian Gulf oil
- specifically, is even greater, their economies for the most
- part have been growing faster than that of the U.S., and thus
- have more room to absorb some slackening.
- </p>
- <p> Nonetheless, they have their own difficulties. Though the
- Japanese economy is still growing robustly, Japan shares U.S.
- worries about rising inflation and interest rates. In addition,
- real estate and stock prices by the end of last year had been
- bid up to what the country's economists concede were ludicrous
- and unsustainable heights. The stock market tailspin was
- largely inevitable, whatever happened to oil, but it may now
- have reached a scary point. Western analysts are worried, for
- example, that Japanese banks invested heavily in real estate
- loans that are going sour and industrial stocks that have
- fallen sharply in price; consequently the banks may have to
- reduce their lending to more productive enterprises. In
- Frankfurt the stock market has been battered by heavy selling
- of stocks (Daimler-Benz, Hoechst) that had previously been
- heavily propped up by Kuwaiti investment.
- </p>
- <p> In Britain inflation had been expected to rise above 10%
- this fall, and the economy seemed to be headed for recession
- as well. No wonder, then, that the threat of war and further
- big oil-price increases pulled the London stock market down
- along with all others. Gerard Holtham, London-based chief
- international economist for Shearson Lehman Hutton, figures
- that the oil-price increases that have already occurred have
- "clinched" a downturn for the U.S., Britain, Canada and
- Australia. Says he: "If you speak English, you're in recession."
- More generally, no nation is likely to be able to resist the
- impact of an oil shortage and further price boosts.
- </p>
- <p> In the Third World such nations as Brazil and Chile may have
- to default on debt repayments to their Western creditors. The
- new democracies of Eastern Europe have had enough trouble
- switching from Soviet oil at a subsidized $7 per bbl. to oil
- bought on world markets at $18; a further leap to $32 or more
- could severely disrupt their efforts to shift from command to
- free-market economies. And the Western industrial world is so
- thoroughly integrated that an inflationary recession in the
- U.S. is certain to have a global impact.
- </p>
- <p> It is possible to foresee a different outcome. A prolonged
- standoff in the gulf might be accompanied by a rise in crude
- production by countries other than Iraq and Kuwait sufficient
- to reverse some of the recent price run-ups. Even war could end
- in a coup overthrowing Saddam Hussein, a quick American victory
- and a vast easing of economic strains. But it would be risky
- to bet on any such outcome. Last week's upheaval in the
- financial markets might have been an overreaction to what has
- happened so far, but unhappily it cannot be dismissed as
- mindless panic. In a few months it could even look like a sober
- reappraisal of darkening prospects for the world economy.
- </p>
-
- </body>
- </article>
- </text>
-
-